Vibe Coding: I Put Replit, Lovable and Firebase Studio to the Test
š Vibe coding, I put Replit, Lovable and Firebase Studio to the test.
- Same AI prompt.
- Different results.
- Here's what I found š
The Prompt
Inspired by a real project I worked on in early 2000s ā a cash flow management system for a fund manager, I decided to rebuild parts of the solution I call "QuantumFlow".
I told all these #AI engines to build a predictive, real-time platform that helps fund managers: š§ Manage liquidity š Minimize risk š Automate forecasting + reporting
The Experiment
I asked all 3 tools to generate the same prototype UI and logic.
My Findings
1. Speed
- ā” Firebase = fastest to prototype logic
- ā” Replit = fastest to render the UI
2. UI + Navigation
- ā Replit & Lovable nailed the layout
- ā Lovable interface was slightly better than replit
- ā Lovable ignored mobile optimization
- š§ Firebase left too many "under construction" pages and seemed buggy
3. Features
- š Replit generated the richest features
- š Lovable missed reports but had second best coverage
- š¦ All 3 created accounts, funds & reporting flows without extra prompts
4. Ease of Use
- š” Replit had the most intuitive interface
- šÆ Closest to what I'd expect in production
- š If you're building prototypes with AI, choose wisely.
5. Bugs / Issue Resolution
- Replit scored the best at fixing issues viz broken pages and scripts
- Firebase had trouble fixing problems
Overall
#Replit impressed me the most
- understanding context
- interface quality
- feature richness
- intelligent defaults
#Lovable
- best interface
- feature coverage could be better
- some good defaults & settings
#Firebase
- Least impressive on feature coverage and interface
- But integrates with Google / GCP
What's your go-to AI app builder? If you would like to see my prompt, comment prompt below...